The American Pie Company: Indulge in Authentic American Comfort Food

Hmm. Something happened to American Pie Company. Something good. We just tried the cottage pie again after a few years' hiatus. This time, it was made with real potatoes -- real red-skinned potatoes -- mashed to a perfectly creamy consistency with a few pleasant chunks left for texture, and most importantly, made without margarine! Underneath a thick layer of potatoey goodness, the ground beef / carrot / corn stew was flavorful and nicely seasoned. The potato to stew ratio was about 1:1, so it was admittedly a touch high by some standards. And IIRC, the pie pan now seems to be more shallow / smaller what it was on our last try... But if one values quality over quantity, this iteration is a significant improvement. I don't know if these well-made, margarine-free mashed potatoes were a post-Thanksgiving fluke or not, but we're curious enough to try our luck again!

Just stopped in for coffee and a cookie... staff was wonderfully pleasant... can't wait to return for a full meal soon!

American Pie Company offers an exceptional diner experience. And do not miss out on the bevy of delicious baked goods in front! We saw no need to over complicate things. The Chicken Pot Pie, the house speciality, is excellent. Something about it just tastes homemade. The crust is flaky, crispy and light, and it is stuffed with choice chunks of chicken and veggies. Also, unless you happen to play offensive line for your local NFL team, this is not a personal-sized portion. It is meant to be shared and could readily serve as lunch for three. The service was also great. We had a big group and no reservation, then also asked to change tables after ordering. (Admittedly annoying). The servers were extremely accommodating though and helped make our lunch dreams true.

Whatever I have ordered at American Pie is always tasty and fresh, whether for breakfast, lunch, dinner. It is always a great place for a slice of pie and coffee.

Stopped to get a pie. We didn't try the restaurant. Everyone was friendly and helpful. Bought a peach raspberry pie and two of the awesome looking cookies in display area. The pie was incredible!! It reminded me of my great aunt's peach pie. The cookies on the other hand were inedible. We got a snicker doodle and m&m. The where so stale. The snickerdoodle had little flavor and the m&m has a burnt weird flavor. We had one bite and threw them out. I wish we lived closer. (We live on the shoreline). I would getting my Thanksgiving pies there!

Cute breakfast spot that serves up big plates and hospitality! Came for breakfast Friday morning and as you enter through the bakery side, you can see all their pies, cookies and cupcakes. The dining area off to the right is cute and charming. Service is friendly and food portions are huge! 1 cute thing they, any item off the kids menu gets a free cookie from the bakery. My daughter was very happy as she got to pick out a cookie of her choice.

The perfect sendoff after a weekend in CT. The breakfast here is so good and priced to perfection. The space inside is homey and cozy -- great for families and bigger groups. We came here as a group of 4 on Sunday around 1pm and sat immediately. Service was good, staff is friendly. Oatmeal Pancakes: Served with warm spiced apples on top, these 3 pancakes are fluffy and sweet on their own, with a bit of crunch inside from the nuts (which almost seem candied). At $15 for 3 excellent pancakes, I found these to be a great deal. The spiced apples absolutely made this dish. These were great with a side of bacon and eggs as well. Value: 5/5 Quality: 5/5 Quantity: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Atmosphere: 4/5

The vibe is warm and friendly. The pies and desserts are delicious. you can come and just grab and go, or you can be seated and served. The food is very much comfort food and it's very good. i've come here whenever i'm in the neighborhood. I love their french onion soup.

Always delicious. Never a disappointing meal. The food is just delicious whether you came for breakfast or lunch, the menu boasts something for everyone The chicken pot pie is one of their signature dishes and a must have. A great place to meet friends or for a family dinner. Check out the bakery before you leave, the rainbow cookies are delish!!

Deliciously great breakfast! The portions are very hearty also. The service was so great you wouldn't know that there was only one waitress taking care of a full restaurant at 9:30am. Excellent job! The sausage gravy was scrumptious. And the cheese crepe divine. Definitely a go to.